BTIG is taking a contrarian stance on consumer staples, arguing the segment is both under-owned and out of favor despite recent market leadership. Strategist Jonathan Krinsky says investor reception to his bullish call on staples has been muted, noting that many market participants reserve staples for times when a recession is considered probable.
Krinsky contrasts the current sentiment toward staples with the summer’s interest in artificial intelligence names, where he says the bullish narrative was simple and ownership was already widespread by June. By comparison, he sees staples as lacking investor ownership even after a period of relative strength.
To support his view, Krinsky points to several performance and sentiment metrics. He notes that an equal-weight consumer staples ETF remains roughly 4% below its February high, indicating the rally has not fully retraced earlier losses. He also compares longer-term relative performance: since May 2023 the equal-weight S&P 500 has advanced about 52%, while equal-weight staples have declined approximately 7%. On a technical basis, staples are only now pushing out of a three-year downtrend versus the broader market.
Campbell’s is identified as a clear example of Krinsky’s thesis. He describes the company as a security that is widely unloved: it carries no Buy ratings from Wall Street analysts, its average price target sits about 20% below the current market price, and roughly 20% of its shares are held short. Despite that constellation of negative indicators, the stock has begun to move higher, breaking out above an eight-month trading range - a development that would leave short sellers who bet against the stock since March sitting on losses.
Krinsky says the combination of limited ownership and pervasive negativity can create a potent setup and highlights scope for a pronounced upward move toward $30 for Campbell’s.
Beyond Campbell’s, Krinsky also points to other staples that are heavily shorted yet present technically constructive charts. These include Boston Beer, Reynolds Consumer Products, Vita Coco, Simply Good Foods and Kraft Heinz. In naming these names, he is signaling a broader pattern within the staples complex rather than isolating his thesis to a single company.
Analysis of the sector, according to Krinsky, rests on the argument that sentiment is not reflecting recent price behavior and that ownership metrics remain low. He rejects the notion that the recent rally in staples means the trade is exhausted, citing both relative performance data and technical breakouts in individual names as reasons to consider the space for contrarian positioning.
The outlook presented by BTIG focuses on market positioning, sentiment, and technical signals rather than on fundamental changes specific to any one company. Where clear numerical indicators are available - such as average price targets, short interest, and comparative ETF performance - Krinsky highlights those figures to explain why staples could attract renewed investor attention.