A federal judge in Manhattan on Friday denied the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s request for a temporary restraining order aimed at stopping New York Attorney General Letitia James from moving forward with an enforcement action against Kalshi, a prediction markets operator.
U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield concluded the CFTC had "not established a likelihood of success on the merits" of its argument that federal law preempts state enforcement of gambling-related laws against operators of prediction markets. The CFTC had asked for an emergency hearing to block New York’s activity after a procedural ruling shifted the case’s forum.
Schofield observed that federal appeals courts have split on whether states may regulate Kalshi and similar platforms. She noted three appellate panels have found states could exercise regulatory authority over Kalshi, while a fourth appellate decision held that New Jersey could not regulate the activity. Schofield said that the split among appellate courts increases the probability that the U.S. Supreme Court will ultimately take up the dispute.
The judge’s decision followed a separate ruling by U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick in Manhattan, who the previous day granted New York’s request to remand the lawsuit back to the Manhattan state court where it was initially filed on July 31. That remand prompted the CFTC to seek an expedited, late-afternoon hearing to temporarily halt the state’s enforcement actions.
In seeking emergency relief, the CFTC argued that returning the case to state court left "no practical barrier to New York moving full steam ahead" against Kalshi. The regulator treats Kalshi’s contracts as "swaps" and has initiated litigation against 12 states to defend what it describes as its exclusive authority over U.S. derivatives markets.
New York Attorney General Letitia James contends that Kalshi should have obtained a license from the New York State Gaming Commission to operate its platform. The platform allows users to trade on the predicted outcomes of events such as sports and elections. James has argued such platforms can contribute to problem gambling and pose risks to participants’ financial, emotional and physical well-being.
Schofield’s refusal to grant the CFTC’s emergency request leaves the state enforcement path intact for now while the broader jurisdictional fight continues through the courts. Given the existing division among appellate courts, the issue of whether federal law preempts state gambling regulations in the context of prediction markets remains unresolved at the national level.