New York state lawmakers have advanced a plan to levy a surcharge on high-value second homes located in New York City with the stated aim of generating $500 million for the state budget. The surcharge is part of the state's postponed $268 billion fiscal plan and would take effect if approved in a scheduled vote on Wednesday.
Under the proposal, the new charge would begin on July 1. Property owners who are subject to the surcharge would receive formal notices by August 30 and would have an opportunity to challenge the assessment through an appeal process.
Officials in the governor's office estimate the measure would reach roughly 10,000 properties across the city, including single-family residences, cooperative apartments and condominiums. The plan explicitly exempts properties that serve as a primary residence, those that are occupied by immediate family members, and those that are leased as rentals.
The levy is structured to roll out in two phases. For the initial two years after enactment, single-family homes with valuations of $5 million or more would be subject to rates ranging from 0.8% to 1.3%. During that same early period, co-ops and condominiums valued at $1 million or higher would face steeper rates, between 4% and 6.5%.
Beginning July 1, 2028, the proposal moves to a single, uniform rate schedule that applies to all property types with assessed values of $5 million or more. Under that longer-term structure, properties valued between $5 million and $15 million would be taxed at 0.8%. Units or homes valued between $15 million and $25 million would be assessed at 1.05%, and properties worth $25 million or more would face a 1.3% rate.
The current text of the plan removes a previously discussed element that would have targeted all-cash property purchases. That option is not included in the proposal now before legislators.
This measure is intended to be revenue-generating within the confines of the state's delayed budget process. The proposal sets specific timelines and valuation bands, outlines notifications and appeals for affected owners, and establishes clear exemptions for primary residences, family-occupied units and rental properties.