Wendy A. Rummler, who serves as Chief People Officer at Credit Acceptance Corp (NASDAQ:CACC), reported a set of related transactions in the company’s common stock on April 17, 2026. On that date Ms. Rummler sold a total of 4,062 shares for aggregate proceeds of $2,135,285 and contemporaneously acquired 4,062 shares by exercising employee stock options, paying a total of $1,356,464 to convert those options into common stock.
The company’s shares were trading at $521.20 at the time of the report. Year-to-date the stock has returned 22%, and according to InvestingPro the shares are trading below its Fair Value estimate. Credit Acceptance’s valuation metrics cited in the report include a price-to-earnings ratio of 14.48, a PEG ratio of 0.16, and a market capitalization of approximately $5.6 billion.
The disposal of shares was executed across multiple transactions at varying prices. The largest block comprised 2,742 shares sold at a weighted average price of $525.26 per share, with individual sale prices ranging from $525.00 to $525.64. A second block of 1,205 shares was sold at a weighted average price of $526.42 per share, with trade prices between $526.13 and $527.09. A final, smaller lot of 115 shares was sold at a weighted average price of $527.71 per share, with individual sales recorded between $527.63 and $527.72.
The 4,062-share acquisition resulted from exercising employee stock options that carried an exercise price of $333.94 per share. Those options were granted with an exercise date of December 30, 2024 and an expiration date of December 30, 2026. Following these transactions, Ms. Rummler directly holds 19,547.1 shares of Credit Acceptance common stock.
In addition to her direct holdings, Ms. Rummler retains indirect ownership positions: 2,704 shares through the Kevin Rummler Revocable Trust and 2,365.5 shares through the Wendy A. Rummler Revocable Trust.
Ms. Rummler also continues to hold a portfolio of unexercised employee stock options. Among these are options to purchase 10,000 shares at an exercise price of $468.67, which vest in four equal annual installments beginning October 6, 2023 and expire on October 6, 2028. She additionally holds options to acquire 1,250 shares with an exercise price of $390.39 that become exercisable from April 28, 2025 and expire on April 28, 2027.
These insider transactions occurred in the context of recent quarterly results from Credit Acceptance. For its fiscal fourth quarter of 2025 the company reported earnings per share of $11.35, ahead of the consensus expectation of $10.01, representing a 13.39% surprise to the upside. Revenue for the quarter totaled $579.9 million, slightly below the expected $584 million.
Following the earnings release, Stephens raised its price target on Credit Acceptance to $540 from $450 while maintaining an Equal Weight rating. In its update Stephens cited improving fundamentals and referenced the leadership of newly appointed CEO Vinayek Hegde and the company’s emphasis on digital transformation as points of focus ahead of the firm’s first-quarter 2026 earnings report.
Taken together, the option exercise and share sales update Ms. Rummler’s direct and indirect holdings and reflect standard equity compensation activity around scheduled option terms. The company’s recent operating results and the analyst adjustment to the price target provide additional context for investors monitoring insider activity at Credit Acceptance.